Reinhard Donath: Englischunterricht in der Informationsgesellschaft
E.Mail-Projekte WWW Hypertext CD-ROMs DaF Didaktik
Literatur   Veröffentlichungen   Person  
 
Perth Western Australia

Unit 5: Some special aspects for individual research

a mysterious table in town

ships, sheep and more about Fremantle

 

Ships, sheep and more about Fremantle
or: what Fremantle and Papenburg have in common

MV Oriana - built in Papenburg/EmsLivestock carrier

 

 

 

 

 

 

Well, yes, you might have got an idea of Fremantle, its historic prison, convict history etc. Fremantle has got a big harbour as well which sees two totally different kinds of ships regularly: Livestock carriers, transporting live sheep (about 70,000 of them on board) mainly to the Middle East and luxurious cruise liners, shipping well-off tourists round the Indian and Pacific Ocean.

"The ORIANA for P&O Cruises, delivered in April 1995, was the first
cruise liner specially conceived for the British market. With a
normal running speed of 24 knots the ORIANA is one of the fastest
ships in the world and is therefore also equipped for world cruise"

from: http://www.meyerwerft.com 

MV Oriana

"Bali was very pushy as far as the locals trying to sell things. The tour guide in Bali was very well informed and managed to give us cultural and historical background to the many places we visited. The art work in Bali is beautiful and the people seem very friendly and outgoing. Australia is my home so when we docked in Fremantle, Western Australia it brought a lump to my throat. We had a special welcome here with a girls school band playing and lots of people to greet the ship. Perth and Fremantle would have to be one of the most attractive cities to visit. The trip on the Swan River was a memory I will cherish for a long time."

quotetd from: http://travelpage.com/yourfav/cruise/yfc_po_oriana.htm 

"P & O SUPERLINERS – 50% OFF!!
"Oriana" 15 Feb – 14 nts – SYDNEY-HONG KONG via Fremantle & Bali from A$3690 including o’night accom, transfers and airfare back to Australia from Hong Kong"

quoted from: http://www.cruiseabout.com.au/pr02.htm 

What livestock carriers and cruise liners have in common? Some of the livestock carriers transporting live sheep to the Middle East countries were converted from cargo vessels into livestock carriers (sheep freighters) by a ship-yard in this area: Meyer Werft Papenburg - were the Oriana was built as well and even bigger cruise liners are are being built and have already been ordered. Good for the economy of Ostfriesland and the Emsland, more than 1,000 people are working there, nearly 50% of them from Ostfriesland. But what about the river Ems and the Sperrwerk? Doesn't look easy to say this is right - this is wrong, I think. But back to Fremantle, Australia.

Livestock Carriers

"AL SHUWAIKH"
With a capacity of 125,000 sheep, the largest livestock carrier in the world.
This livestock carrier, developed and converted by Meyer Werft, has at its disposal the following equipment 

- Automatic fodder system 
- Automatic drinking water supply 
- Combined drinking troughs for both sheep and cattle 
- Horizontal and vertical dung removal system 
- Removable aluminium decks for combined sheep/cattle carriers 
- Pen construction of galvanized material and/or aluminium 
- Optimum ventilation system

Information taken from: http://www.meyerwerft.com 

The following news from Associated Press (5 September 1996) might give you an idea of a problem going along with shipping live sheep:

Ship fire: 67,000 of the animals were left to die

.Associated Press ... 5 September 1996 

PERTH, Australia -- Animal welfare activists called Thursday for an immediate ban on live sheep exports from Australia after 67,000 sheep were left to die on a blazing ship off the east coast of Africa. The 14,990-ton Uniceb, a Panamanian-registered vessel bound for Jordan from Western Australia, caught fire off Tanzania earlier this week.
Fifty-four crew were rescued by a passing freighter, but the stricken vessel's engineer was lost overboard. No crew remained on board. A tug is on its way to salvage the ship, which is adrift, Australian Broadcasting Corp. radio reported Thursday. Other unconfirmed reports said the ship might have sunk. 
Australia regularly exports live sheep to the Middle East, where the animals are slaughtered according to Islamic religious requirements. ''I was horrified by the thought of 67,000 sheep being burned to death or perhaps dying from smoke or possibly dying of thirst,'' said animal rights activist Peter Singer. 

Hugh Wirth, president of the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, condemned the live sheep exports as cruel, saying up to 8 percent of the animals die in transit even during successful voyages. Although the Australian government admits there are problems with live exports, it said the exports are worth $390 million a year and will
continue.

 

Careful: It doesn't really solve any problems, if you just feel angry about this fact or the Ems debate. Start thinking economically as well as ecologically, especially as this is a global phenomenon with a lot of different aspects to be considered before you can say "right" or "wrong" - "terible" or "good":

  • without work, there's no pay -  without money, life is awful
  • people look for work on a farm, on board a ship, as a trucker, etc.
  • farmers want to sell their animals, ship-builders their ships
  • religious reasons have to be taken into account
  • do you really know where the meat on your plate originally comes from and how it was transported?
  • and suddenly there is a connection between a Malayan sailor working on board a ship, converted in Papenburg perhaps by a relative or neighbour of yours, working at the Meyer Werft

 

Research-task no 1: Find out about the transport of live sheep from Fremantle to the Middle EastLivestock Carrier and Arabian countries. Where do the sheep come from? How are they transported to Fremantle? Why are they shipped alive and not frozen? What are the problems going along with this according to animal welfare campaigners? How important is the export of sheep to the Australian economy (or Australian farmers)?

You might start with one of the following links but it might be helpful to use a search engine like www.alltheweb.com and the search-words 

+Fremantle +sheep +"Middle East"

Shipped sheep:  http://www.cyber-dyne.com/~tom/sheep_die.html 

Animal Liberation (South Australia)

Live Export: Fact Sheet 6

The Ships of Shame

Research-task no 2: Find out about the port of Fremantle